Let’s talk about books and copyrights for a second. I recently came across a reel where a fellow author calls out a very specific section of licensing notes in a printed edition of an Indie book, and I have thoughts.
Before I get into that, though, I want to make clear that this is in no way intended to criticize this particular content creator, or what they said, which is why I’m not sharing the reel, or naming the creator. They were partly correct, and I’m not disputing that.
But the first thing I thought when I saw it was, “What was the purpose behind sharing this information?” And maybe this is my own experience as an Indie coloring my perspective, but it flashed me back to all the controversy and hate that has surrounded self-publishing pretty much since the beginning of self-publishing, and how content like this only serves to perpetuate that negative stereotype.
There are a lot of things for which I could and have called out Indie authors in the past. This is not one of them.
On Intellectual Property and Copyright Protection
Intellectual property refers to anything you come up with that is an original idea or creation. This can be art, music, a story, or even a new technological invention. In the US, by law, you are the legal owner of your intellectual property the moment it is created. No further action needed.
However, it is very difficult to prove ownership beyond the shadow of a doubt in a court of law. That is where Copyrights come in. You can register your original work for a copyright certificate. This serves as legally admissible proof that you are the original creator and the owner of that work. For written works of fiction, the certificate protects your work until you die and 75 years after your death.
Important to note here that when it comes to literary works (books, poems, etc.) a writer only owns the content of the work, not the format in which it is presented.
Ebook vs. Print
This is where the above distinction becomes important. What’s the difference between a printed book and a digital one?
A printed book is a physical product you buy and own. When you buy it, you have the right to do anything you want with it: resell it, gift it, destroy it, loan it out, etc. When that product leaves your hand, you lose access to it. It goes from you to someone else, but there is still only one product moving back and forth.
An eBook is not a product. When you buy it, you do not have ownership of it. What you’re buying is a license to access the content of that book. This is an important distinction. Because an eBook is a digital file, when you send it to someone, it does not leave your possession. What you did is essentially create a copy of the content (which is copyright-protected), while retaining your original, and there is no physical limit to how many times it can be done.
This is referred to as digital piracy and is not only unethical, it is illegal.
Digital Rights Management
To prevent digital piracy, eBook stores and distributors apply Digital Rights Management (DRM), which is a little bit of code that’s added to the eBook file and makes it so that only the person who purchased it can open the file to access the content.
Unfortunately, it’s not fool-proof and can be removed with the right (or should I say wrong) tools. This creates a massive and very expensive problem for authors who lose out on potential sales, as one share in a forum or group chat can lead to hundreds of thousands of illegal downloads.
Now for a bit of background…
Even a few years ago, Indie authors had two options for book distribution: Smashwords, and Draft2Digital. Smashwords only handled eBooks. Draft2Digital had a built-in service for print books as well. They even made it easy and allowed authors to use their existing eBook files to create print editions.
I know I’m dumping a lot of info on you, but I promise it will make sense in the end. Bear with me a bit longer.
Smashwords was my distributor of choice. And let me tell you, I did my homework on them so I’d know what I was getting into.
Smashwords did not use DRM for their eBooks. Their business model, and what authors agreed to when they signed up for their service, was based on trust. Your reader bought a book, trust them to handle it ethically.
However, you can give them a gentle reminder that the content of your book is still copyright-protected as an encouragement to listen to the angel on their shoulder, not the devil. Below is a screenshot of the exact passage from the Smashwords Style Guide that spells this out verbatim. This guide is still available and free on Smashwords.com, so you can check it out yourself to confirm I’m not making this up.
And this is almost verbatim what the content creator called out in their reel. One paragraph of text on the copyright page of a printed book that didn’t belong. They (correctly) pointed out that this text is not legally enforceable. An author cannot tell you what you can or can’t do with a physical copy of their book—as long as you don’t scan or copy it in its entirety to share illegally.
But this is where I have an issue with it.
The creator presented this as a new and alarming trend among Indie books. Did not call out anyone specifically, but the label still stood out. Because, of course it would be Indie authors doing it, those unethical bastards. You’d never see something like that in a traditionally published book.
Correct. You wouldn’t.
You want to know why?
An Oopsie of Epic Proportions
Fast forward to a couple of years ago, Smashwords gets acquired by their direct competitor, Draft2Digital and shut down their distribution channels, becoming an eBook store only. This made a lot of authors very upset, myself included. With this move, Draft2Digital essentially became a monopoly for the eBook distribution. Yes, there are other options for authors, but realistically, they don’t make sense for most of us.
We’re talking millions of authors around the world and tens of millions of their books. The vast majority of them had no real choice but to go along with it, and their accounts got migrated to the Draft2Digital dashboard.
Now they had immediate access to quickly and easily convert all of their eBooks into print for no additional cost. Just click through, choose your style, get your cover page converted, and boom: your book is now for sale as a paperback.
How many of them do you think took advantage of that opportunity?
How many do you think took the time to go through their catalog of Smashwords-formatted eBooks to check the licensing page for content that might not be relevant for a print edition?
Don’t assume malice…
I’m not saying that this is 100% the reason why that text is suddenly appearing in printed Indie books. I’m just saying, maybe we shouldn’t jump to conclusions without all the necessary information.
Because which of these options makes more logical sense:
- Indie authors everywhere suddenly decided to jump on a trend of threatening their readers because it just sounded like a good idea at the time
OR - A massive number of Indie authors forgot about a default setting and bulk-converted their eBooks into print to take advantage of a great opportunity to reach more readers
To reiterate:
- The Smashwords licensing note was recommended for all non-free eBooks published and distributed through their platform.
- It is not legally enforceable for print books, but also is not illegal to include in said print books.
- Most readers don’t spend a lot of time examining the copyright page of the book they just purchased, and likely had no idea this paragraph was even there until it was pointed out to them.
And so I ask myself again: What was the purpose of calling it out?
In case you’re wondering, yes, as a former Smashwords author, I do still have that particular licensing note in all of my eBooks. No, they do not appear in my print editions, because I format those separately and publish/distribute though a different vendor.
But, being a total control freak, I am the exception, not the rule.
Just saying, in this year of our apocalyptic dystopia 2026, I would hope we’d have learned that Indie authors deserve a bit more grace than we originally gave them.
Thanks for reading.
Until next time!
